pennsicdance: Music from the pennsic Pile
lindahl at pbm.com
Thu Mar 30 21:33:52 PST 2000
> Who said they didn't? But because they had part arrangements does
> not mean that they didn't also do mono/heterophony. Just because we
> have modern dance bands using part arrangements doesn't mean we don't
> have bands not using parts.
Right. I was just pointing out what I knew, not what I could speculate
> I've long thought that myself, but I'm beginning now to wonder if
> that's not a burdensome requirement upon the Pile.
Well, I disagree. If you owned the Pile, you could do what you liked
> It being the
> Pennsic Pile, and not "This Year's Advances in Dance Music", if there
> is a conflict between providing good music for pick up bands and being
> a vehicle for new arrangements, shouldn't the second of those goals
> give way?
I think it can do both. You may not think that. So be it.
> > For
> > example, if you have done any arrangements since Pennsic 24 or so,
> > I've never seen them.
> ... so why should I send you mine for the Pile? Consistency from year
> to year is a value.
I like seeing music for more reasons than definitely putting it in the
> I'm happy to give you copies of my arrangements -- I intend to put
> them on the web (am short of tuits). But I don't necessarily write to
> beginners. I have some bored bass players, one with a penchant for
> eighthnotes. Thus, my "Rusty Tufty" probably REALLY doesn't belong in
> front of a pickup band.
So, apparently, you take your definition of the Pile, and from that
decide you won't submit to someone else's definition of the Pile?
> Would I like to get my music out to more people? Sure, I suppose
> (though not sufficiently enough to motivate me, evidently, to spend
> more time doing so.)
Especially since I hope you remember I publish all sorts of music on
the web, not just the stuff in the pile. So a few minutes of your time
is probably worth a dozen tuits...
> But the Pennsic Pile shouldn't serve arrangers
> at the expense of the Pennsic Dance Band.
In your opinion. I think it can do both. I think you underestimate how
many pages I'm willing to give away every year. And it's a
self-fulfilling prophecy, given that I get basically no submissions of
new music, and very little interest from musicians in using the
Pile. No chicken, no egg, but plenty of back-seat drivers. Not that
I'm frustrated about it, or anything...
To unsubscribe from this list, send email to majordomo at pbm.com containing
the words "unsubscribe pennsicdance". If you are subscribed to the digest
version, say "unsubscribe pennsicdance-digest". To contact a human about
problems, send mail to owner-pennsicdance at pbm.com
More information about the pennsicdance