Musical authenticity (was "Hunting the Wren")

White Tree Productions ioseph at
Sun Sep 10 15:48:46 PDT 1995

On Sun, 10 Sep 1995, Dave & Laura McKinstry wrote:

> Brett Williams wrote:

> >It's my feeling that if we exclude the unprovable then it would lead 
> >one to a natural conclusion that not only should we exclude the 
> >unproven, but also our own efforts as well. I, for one, fail to see the 
> >difference, from the viewpoint of absolute authenticity standards, 
> >between reinterpretation of fragments of period balladry/songs and 
> >original effort. Both are, at heart, according to the cry of the 
> >authenticity maven, "not period".

And thereby limiting us to that small group of provably period songs..feh!

> for the period songs I would sing.  THe melodies, at best, stayed relatively
> the same, but not even that.  Some harpers would overhear a song in a
> tavern, or somesuch, then later recreate it as best they remembered on their
> own instrument, sometimes trying to recall the words, or change the
> rendition to reflect their own values.

This is called the "folk process" and is quite common indeed in traditional

> as I stated in an earlier post, I believe the INTENT of being a bard is to
> tell us of OUR history, so you will more likely hear me sing of Richard of
> Huntington's (Trimaris) three stags on his coat of arms than, say, Queen
> Elizabeth.  

Hear! Hear!

 locksley at          PO Box 35190          Locksley Plot Systems
 White Tree Productions       Phoenix, AZ 85069             CyberMongol Ltd
         "Do not ascribe your own motivations to others. At best, 
            it will break your heart, at worst, get you dead."             
*song lyrics at  pub/sca/locksley  - tapes at 1-510-735-9663*
          For a Good Time, call 

More information about the minstrel mailing list