hist-brewing: Slow Ferment
NATHAN T MOORE
NTMOORE at SMTPGATE.DPHE.STATE.CO.US
Wed Jul 7 13:28:05 PDT 1999
Wow, I guess I am on a Post-oThon today, sorry guys, but here I go...
>Lowering the temperature will slow the yeast activity. Always. (Well,
>between 32 and 120 degrees F, anyway.) But this is not necessarily
>a bad thing. Even lager yeasts ferment more actively at higher
>temperature; however, their products won't be as clean.
This is undisputable and has been proven by several experiments, of
course I dont know if anyone has ever discovered what the ideal temp or
lowest functional temp is and that would be based on yeast strain, but
we know cooling the temperature improves the mead. Until proven
otherwise, we will call this a FACT.
>We want quick starts to stave off infection. Fresh must is much
>more susceptible to infection than must once it is active. Once
>you have a well-established colony of the happy beasties, outsiders
>don't have much chance to cause problems. We want to eliminate
>the period during which the yeast is just waking up and beginning
This also, we can call a FACT, for BEER. However, I dont think this is all
that big of an issue with mead. Of course I would not leave an open
must sitting around asking for trouble, but I personally have never
experienced an infection in my mead And, the biggest reason we try to
shorten the lag with beer is DMS, and the issue there is more with the pH
of the beer wort then competition from yeast.
One example is making fruit wine and ciders with the natural yeasts on
the fruit. Very slow start, all kinds of exposure to beasties, but the
results are often better then anything you could make with store bought
yeast. Yes, I am comparing apples and honey combs here, but I think
mead is a lot closer to wine then beer. And if we used our beer books to
make fruit wine, we would be calling this natural fermentation method a
dumb idea, and missing out on a fun and interesting method.
>Shortening the propagation stage is also desirable for
>production efficiency reasons. During this phase the yeast
>s using the food (your honey) to make more yeast and CO2
>both of which you discard as by-products) instead of alcohol
>(your mead, do not discard). If you have a large active
>colony to begin with, you can bypass much of the propagation
>phase and proceed to anaerobic fermentation.
I have not said that I am sure that under pitching the yeast is a
guaranteed way to make better mead. Hell, I have not even tried it yet, I
currently pitch as much yeast as I can get worked up. What I am saying
is that we have a couple data points pointing to the fact that it MAY be a
method that makes good mead. Why? I do not know. The sciences
about how yeast works is simple and can be looked up in any of a
handfull of books. But understanding the chemical reactions is only half
of the art. Some of it you just have to try. Maybe the point about
consuming sugars during propagation has something to do with it, this
would correspond to Als results of ending up with a dryer, smother
mead because you would be consuming sugars w/o producing alcohol.
So maybe by pitching dry yeast w/o a starter you are actually just
producing a lower alcohol mead from the same amount of honey, which
would appeal to many tastes. This makes since, but it is just a guess.
My point is that someone has told us that they make good meads using
this method, and I do not think we should just pull out our brewing texts
and say "you are wrong" Anyway, I personally will do a split batch
experiment and report my results in a year or so. I'll track all sorts of
variables and then have blind tastings. It will just be one more data point,
but it will help. I also try to work in my bee pollen experiment with this,
though I have not convinced myself it would be wise to through whole
bees into the must :)
To unsubscribe from this list, send email to majordomo at pbm.com containing
the words "unsubscribe hist-brewing" (or unsubscribe hist-brewing-digest, if
you get the digest.) To contact a human about problems, send mail to
owner-hist-brewing at pbm.com
More information about the hist-brewing